Subscribe | Unsubscribe
Hello lovely Reader,
Wanna see something wild? Weight loss ads haven’t changed at all in 100 years.
Which means your great-grandmother, your grandmother, your mom, and now you, all received the same body shaming, fictional beauty standard lies that have built the global weight management market to $591 billion.
Let me prove it to you.
[Content note for advertising mind-fuckery in weight loss ads]
Then: Lucky Strike
In 1928, Lucky Strike, a cigarette company, told women that “Overweight is banished when you banish fattening sweets and light a Lucky instead.”
The campaign worked so well that the candy industry threatened to sue, even as Lucky Strike’s market share went up 200%.
Now: Ro
Ninety-five years later, Ro, a telehealth company heavily offering GLP-1s, covered the walls of New York subway stations with an ad that could have come out of Lucky Strike’s art department.
Take a closer look…
The feeling for sale is being at ease in your body. The Lucky Strike woman lifts her chin with her eyes closed and her shoulders bare, and the Ro woman raises her arms over her head with her belly bare. Diet culture teaches us to hold our bellies in and cover our arms, then sells the ease back to us as something we’ll feel once we buy the product.
The product looks as ordinary and safe as the woman’s own body. The Lucky Strike pack is tucked at her elbow, and the Ro pen is pressed into her belly. And Ro pressed the pen into the part of the body we’ve been taught to be most ashamed of, aiming the ad right at that shame.
The headline never says the word fat, so you fill it in yourself. Lucky Strike promises “To keep a slender figure,” and Ro promises “A weekly shot to lose weight.” The ad stays polite while your own shame does the work. Even the colour is the same soft yellowy green, fresh and calm.
The reassurance hides in tiny print, where it settles your worries without inviting questions. Lucky Strike promises “It’s toasted,” with “No Throat Irritation” and “No Cough” underneath, answering the fear about smoking before you can say it. Ro promises “with coaching, care, and healthy lifestyle changes to make it last,” and if the weight comes back, that line has already made it your fault.
Then: Marmola
All through the 1920s and into the 1930s, women could walk into a drugstore and buy a diet pill with side effects including stopping their heart. Marmola was a “prescription tablet” made of dried animal thyroid and laxatives.
In 1935, TIME magazine warned that Marmola could damage the heart or kill. The Federal Trade Commission took Marmola all the way to the Supreme Court in 1931, and Marmola won. It took eleven more years and a new law before the government could make it stop lying in its ads.
Now: Wegovy, Novo Nordisk
This past February, Novo Nordisk bought its first ever Super Bowl ad to launch the Wegovy pill, and it sells the pill the same way Marmola sold its tablets, calling it “Prescription medicine” in “semaglutide tablets,” taken once daily.
And like Marmola, the Wegovy pill has drawn warnings from regulators. Days before the game, the FDA told Novo Nordisk that a different TV ad for the Wegovy pill made false or misleading claims. The Wegovy pill is also still selling.
Take a closer look…
The promise is a simple daily routine that ends with a “normal” body. Marmola told women to “take four tablets daily until weight comes down to normal,” and Wegovy promises to help adults “lose weight and keep the weight off.” The word “normal” tells you your body isn’t, and “keep the weight off” quietly turns the pill into something you keep buying.
Glamour stands in for the people who actually take the pill. Marmola drew its “1929 Belles” as elegant illustrations, and Wegovy hired Kenan Thompson and a lineup of celebrities, with white text in the corner saying they’re “All actors, not intended to represent Wegovy patients.” We already like and trust these famous faces, so that trust carries straight over to the pill, even though we have no idea if any of them them are taking it.
Your body gets blamed for everything that’s hard in your life. Marmola promised to “end the excess in this easy way,” and the whole Super Bowl spot asks whether you’d take a pill to make everything in life easier. Once weight is tied to every struggle, a pill that changes your weight sounds like it will fix all of them.
Then: Redusols
Another popular diet pill included dinitrophenol (DNP), a chemical used to make dyes and explosives, and was sold over the counter with no warning label under names like Slim and Formula 281. Formula 281 promised “a figure men admire and women envy, without danger to your health.”
By 1935, eye doctors were seeing an epidemic of cataracts, mostly in young women, and some of those women went completely blind while others died. The pills stayed on drugstore shelves until a new law finally made selling them illegal in 1938.
Now: GLP-1s
As of November 2026, more than 270 federal lawsuits claim GLP-1s caused NAION, a condition that damages the optic nerve and can cause partial or complete vision loss.
Take a closer look…
Diet pill makers figured out early that a famous face sells better than any list of ingredients. The Dilex Institute sold its Redusols with a testimonial from J. J. Lyons, a former New York Secretary of State. Almost a hundred years later, Ro sells GLP-1s with Serena Williams, and the layout is essentially the same.
Big numbers make the result feel fast and certain. Each ad leads with a famous face and puts the pounds and the timeline in the biggest type on the page, “Reduced 18 Pounds in 5 Weeks!” for Lyons and “31 lbs in 20 months on GLP-1s” for Serena. These numbers are chosen for you to easily imagine it on your own body.
Hearing that the old ways failed them makes your own failed diets feel like proof that you need this product. Lyons lost the weight “without diet or tiring exercises,” and Serena “was doing everything right but nothing worked.” If you’ve tried everything too, the ad has already told you what’s left.
Doctors and statistics make a sales pitch sound proven. Redusols were made by “a group of PHYSICIANS,” and the sidebar says Lyons’s letter “reflects the average experience of hundreds of users.” Ro’s fine print points to “FDA-approved medication” and promises “Average weight loss is 20% in 1 year.” Keep reading, though, and that average comes from “the highest doses” of medication, “with diet and exercise.”
The personal stories hide a financial one. The Redusols ad swears Lyons wrote an “unsolicited testimonial.” Serena’s husband, Alexis Ohanian, is an investor in Ro and sits on its board. Draw your own conclusions.
It’s been 100 years of diet culture, anti-fatness, and marketing machines churning out the same old grift.
I’ll confess something. I used to do this for a living. None of these ad choices are accidents. Every pose, every headline, every line of fine print was tested, argued over in a meeting, and approved because it works on us.
Before becoming a coach and rejecting coercive business practices, I spent years in sales and marketing, building campaigns designed to make people feel a need and then buy the thing that promised to meet that need.
With this email, I’m handing you my marketer’s eyes. Next time a weight loss ad finds you, look for the pose, the promise, and the fine print, and notice the lack-of-something it’s trying to make you feel.
You can now recognize the same diet culture pitch your great-grandmother got a hundred years ago.
From Fat Joy headquarters,
P.S.- If you’d like to see the GLP-1 injuries people are currently suing over, the court records are public, and there are a lot of them.
The gastrointestinal injury case. More than 4,000 lawsuits claim that GLP-1s from Novo Nordisk (Ozempic, Wegovy, Rybelsus) and Eli Lilly (Trulicity, Mounjaro) caused gastroparesis (a stomach that stops emptying properly), bowel obstructions, pancreatitis, gallbladder injuries, and in some cases death.
The vision loss case. In December 2025, a court opened a case for people claiming GLP-1s caused NAION, an optic nerve condition that can cause vision loss. It started with about 30 federal lawsuits, and less than a year later, there are 278.
P.P.S.- More marketing fuckery for you because I can't help myself. We've been told for 100 years that fat folks can’t have short hair. I mean, have they not seen the cute shag pixie that I dare to wear with a round face??
P.P.P.S.- Here are the references for each of the ads:
Watch these when... you want the map for how diet culture hacked your personality.
And you want practices you can action right away to get unhacked.
Get this free, 11-episode series that gives you a whole lot of answers. 🤯
|
|